We have been ordering 12 can shipments of this flavor through Amazon for almost a year, however we think the last two shipments were CONTAMINATED causing vomiting and lethargy in our cat! I remembered the pate looked odd so I opened several more cans and found the pate was grey/black with a dark gravy at the bottom! As you know, the pate is usually brown with a light golden broth or gravy on the bottom of the can. I contacted Amazon & was refunded one case but it was too late to get a refund for the two previous orders. I have submitted a review warning other Amazon customers DO NOT BUY Purina Beyond Grain Free, Natural DUCK & SWEET POTATO. It should be recalled!!