The packaging on lash paradise mascara does not say waterproof! The only place its written is on the actual tube in teeny little print thats so small you can barely read it. I bought it twice in one week thinking I was getting the regular one and they were both waterproof! One had a design on it that was different than the other and I thought that was the waterproof one so I bought a different one but it was waterproof too! Its horrible you cant wash it off it doesnt lengthen your lashes like the regular formula. Im out $30 and have to go buy it again Im so mad! I cant understand not writing it on the actual package, Ive been using it for two years and never had this issue and all of a sudden now every time I pick one up its waterproof User's recommendation: Read the tube !!