How to get Auto Owners to pay your claim! Just keep calling and emailing as often as you can! The adjuster, the adjusters supervisor, the regional manager, the VP Mary Pierce, and the CEO Jeff Tagsold. Fill up their email and voice mail everyday. Just keep repeating that you have not received you claim check. No matter what they tell you just call again until the check is in your hand. Their adjusters are trained to ignore customers until the go away. They also keep changing adjusters on you to buy time. Just keep calling daily anyway! They only pay when you are annoying them! User's recommendation: Find a real company.