I have bought 9 to 5 collection Lakme lipstick from Life style Store in R Mall, Mulund Shade no 46 Apple Crush The one which I bought three months ago was a shade which used to become a bit matte but recently purchased one is duplicate as I think which does not give a good texture and is glossy I have both the shades with me right now If any representative can come to my place and collect the shades and analyss it . My e mail Id is [protected]@yahoo.com