Not knowing if I purchased it and it was dry and clunky I only have this product for two weeks I didn't go back for a refund because I thought Revlon was a good product just wanting a fresher product. I have purchased several products from this company Revlon and for me to get it all in one mascara that's very clunky and from the very beginning I don't know if it was all because I've been sitting in the store all of that time I'm not sure but I know because I'm a good customer of using a good product