Lip montly is a bag of low quality brown to salmon lip colors each month. They have gone down hill. When I first subscribed the quality was great and so was the color range. Now every other month has a duplicate item or a dollar tree one. I see what boxycharm can do at such a low price point and i was looking for something similar with lip color. Lip Monthly is not it. I also see the way the respond to their upset customers making excuses and blaming the customer it gives a poor impression of the company as *** The customer is not always right but, condescending responses will get you nowhere. I never had an issue with delivery but, i cancelled before all those issues started. My reason for 1 star is low quality and repetitive color stories.