I have purchased the mule Patty Tayna, in every color for years now. And each pair has come apart at the sole & upper. I've taken them to 2 different shoe repair people & neither were able to repair/save them. I was told to quit buying these Clarks, as it's a very common problem. I am not hard on shoes & have never actually worn out a pair. I regret having to stop buying Clarks as they are very comfortable & come in my small size of 5. But I guess I'm going to have to give up on buying Clarks. Diane Campbell Tucson, AZ