I stopped using my former hair color and switched to Garnier Ultra coverage for my grays. It stayed on my hair nicely as I applied it, didn’t stain skin and the color lasted. Then later on the color cream tube suddenly has a red seal around cap. I mix it, it’s so soupy, it’s dripping down my neck and ears. Color did not last. I called them. “Oh it’s the same product.” No it isn’t. I found a box in rite aid where cream tube had no red seal. Yeah we shall see. Like clairol, they’re screwing around with a perfect product. It will catch up with you later on. Don’t mess with women’s hair. We are observant about products we use. And you can’t fool me.